TMC Shirts

Screen Printing vs DTG: Best for Team T-Shirts?

Screen Printing vs DTG: Best for Team T-Shirts? — key points at a glance
Screen Printing vs DTG: Best for Team T-Shirts? — key points at a glance

By The TMK Shirts Team •

Most teams overpay by choosing the wrong print method before they know their order size. The gap can be as wide as £3 per shirt.

For team t-shirt orders of 24 or more in up to four colours, screen printing delivers the lower unit cost, sharper results on cotton, and prints that survive 50-plus washes. DTG suits orders under 12 shirts or designs with photographic detail.

The choice between screen printing and DTG (direct-to-garment) comes down to three numbers: quantity, colour count, and budget per shirt. Get those right and the decision is straightforward.

How Screen Printing Works

A separate stencil, called a screen, is prepared for each colour in your design. The press then pushes ink through that mesh directly onto the fabric, one colour at a time. Setup carries a one-off cost of roughly £15 to £25 per colour, but once those screens are made, printing 50 shirts costs almost the same as printing 25. At 24 shirts with a two-colour club crest, screen printing typically lands below £6 per shirt using a quality blank such as the Gildan Heavy Cotton T-Shirt, which holds plastisol ink cleanly and comes in a range of sizes.

The finished print sits slightly raised on the fabric, colours stay vivid, and the result survives 50 or more washes without significant fading. That durability is what makes it the default for sports clubs, charity runs, and school events where shirts get worn hard.

How DTG Works

A modified inkjet printer sprays water-based ink onto the garment pixel by pixel. There are no screens to prepare and no per-colour charge. An eight-shirt order with a full-colour photograph is entirely practical. The catch: unit costs at low quantities sit between £12 and £20 per shirt depending on coverage area, which makes DTG a poor fit for a 60-person fun run.

Fabric also matters more here. DTG produces best results on 100% ring-spun cotton. On polyester or blended fabrics the ink bleeds, so most performance sports shirts are a poor candidate for the technique.

The Break-Even Point

As a working guide: below 12 shirts, DTG usually wins on total cost. Between 12 and 24 it depends on colour count. Above 24, screen printing is cheaper and more durable in almost every case. For school teams, office events, or charity fundraisers ordering Fruit of the Loom Valueweight T-Shirts in bulk, screen printing is the standard answer, and the cost savings are easy to see on any quote sheet.

Matching the Method to Your Event

Sports club kit, two colours, 30 shirts: screen printing. Corporate away-day shirts with a full-colour gradient logo, quantity eight: DTG. Charity 10k, 100 shirts, single-colour back print: screen printing without question.

Designs with more than six distinct colours or photographic gradients are where the comparison gets interesting. Ask your printer about simulated process screen printing, which uses halftone dots to reproduce full-colour images and usually beats DTG above 48 pieces on price and wash durability.

For tournaments with 200 players across multiple teams, consistency across every shirt matters more than print technique. Screen printing delivers repeatable colour matching that DTG cannot guarantee across separate batches. Pairing a bulk screen-print order with Gildan Performance Adult T-Shirts covers active sport use while keeping the per-shirt cost at a level that works for team treasurers.

Related Products

Gildan Heavy Cotton T-Shirt

The go-to blank for screen printing. Holds plastisol ink cleanly and available in packs across standard team sizes.

Fruit of the Loom Valueweight T-Shirts

A budget-friendly bulk option for event shirts. Good surface for single or two-colour screen prints.

Gildan Performance Adult T-Shirt

Moisture-wicking fabric for active sport. Works with screen-printed numbers and names on polyester-blend stock.

FAQ

What is the minimum order quantity for screen printing?

Most UK printers set a minimum of 12 to 24 shirts per design to cover screen setup costs. Below that threshold, DTG or heat-transfer vinyl is usually more cost-effective for your total spend.

Can you screen print a photographic image on a t-shirt?

Yes, using a technique called simulated process printing, which reproduces full-colour images through multiple halftone screens. It works well above 50 pieces. For smaller runs with photos, DTG is the simpler and cheaper route.

How many washes does a screen-printed t-shirt last?

A properly cured plastisol screen print typically survives 50 to 75 washes before noticeable fading. Washing inside-out on a cool setting extends that lifespan considerably.

Is DTG printing suitable for team sports shirts?

Generally not. Most sports and performance fabrics contain polyester, which blocks DTG ink adhesion. Screen printing or dye sublimation is a better fit for polyester team kit.

What blank t-shirt is best for custom team printing?

For screen printing, 100% combed or ring-spun cotton at 180 to 200 gsm gives the cleanest result. Gildan Heavy Cotton and Fruit of the Loom Valueweight are the two blanks you will see most often at UK print shops, and both are easy to source in bulk.

Affiliate disclosure: some links in this article are affiliate links. TMC Shirts may earn a small commission if you purchase through them, at no extra cost to you.