Screen Print vs DTG for Custom Team T-Shirts
Most team organisers choose a printing method based on the first quote they receive. On a 50-shirt run, picking the wrong method can add 60% to the per-unit cost.
Screen printing: the case for large runs
Screen printing pushes ink through a mesh stencil, one colour at a time. Setup costs run £15 to £30 per colour for screen preparation. The per-unit price drops sharply as the run grows. A 50-shirt order with a two-colour logo on a Gildan 5000 Heavy Cotton T-Shirt typically lands at £4 to £6 per unit with a UK printer. Adding a third colour costs another £20 to £30 spread across the whole job.
That is why screen printing rewards simple, bold artwork: a club badge, a sponsor name, an event slogan in two or three solid colours. Washability is the other advantage. Screen-printed plastisol ink bonds to the fibre under heat and holds well past 75 washes with basic care.
DTG: when it earns its place
DTG (direct-to-garment) works like a wide-format inkjet printer, except the garment sits on the platen instead of paper. No screens, no setup fees, no charge per colour. A 10-shirt order with a six-colour crest is no more complex to produce than a single-colour run at the same quantity.
DTG handles photographic detail well. If your team shirts carry a full-colour sponsor logo with gradients, or each volunteer at an event gets a personalised name beneath a shared graphic, DTG handles both without plate changes. A Fruit of the Loom Valueweight T-Shirt takes DTG ink cleanly when pre-treated correctly. The trade-off: unit cost stays relatively flat and does not fall the way screen printing does once you pass 48 units.
Side-by-side comparison
| Factor | Screen printing | DTG |
|---|---|---|
| Best quantity | 24 or more | 1 to 23 |
| Colour limit | Cost rises per colour | Unlimited, flat cost |
| Design type | Flat logos, bold text | Photos, gradients |
| Washability | Excellent (75+ washes) | Good with pre-treatment |
| Cost per unit at 50 | Low | Medium to high |
The decision rule
Order 24 or more shirts with a design under four colours? Screen printing. Fewer than 24 shirts, photographic artwork, or mixed personalisation across the batch? DTG.
Sports clubs ordering seasonal kits, or events printing 100-plus matching shirts, get the best cost per unit from screen printing. A heavier blank like the Hanes Beefy-T Original Fit at 185gsm gives the print a premium feel at minimal extra blank cost. For stag parties, small department teams, or charity runs where shirt counts vary per person, DTG removes minimum-run friction entirely.
FAQ
What is the minimum order quantity for screen printing?
Most UK printers set a minimum of 12 to 24 shirts per design. Below 12, setup costs make screen printing uneconomical next to DTG. Some specialist suppliers will go down to 6 shirts for a premium per-unit rate.
Can DTG match Pantone colours accurately?
DTG approximates Pantone colours, but it prints in CMYK and results vary by fabric colour and pre-treatment quality. For exact brand colour matching, particularly on a dark shirt, screen printing with spot inks is more reliable.
Does fabric type affect print quality?
Yes. Both methods work best on 100% cotton. Polyester blends above 50% can cause dye migration in screen printing and poor ink adhesion in DTG. Standard 180gsm ringspun cotton is the safest choice for either method.
What file format should I send for a custom team order?
For screen printing, send vector artwork as an AI, EPS, or PDF file with outlined fonts. For DTG, a high-resolution PNG with a transparent background at 300 dpi works for most printers. Always confirm file specs with your supplier before submitting artwork.
How do I work out the right size split for a team order?
A common split for adult team orders in the UK is 10% S, 25% M, 35% L, 25% XL, 5% XXL. Collect actual size preferences from your group wherever possible; that split is only a fallback for when you cannot survey participants in advance.
Related products
The go-to blank for screen-printed team runs
View on Amazon UKAffordable 165gsm blank for DTG orders
View on Amazon UKHeavier 185gsm blank for events and charity runs
View on Amazon UK